Mozzarella Stuffed Mushroom Burger
Inspired by the Shake Shack mushroom burger, this Mozzarella Stuffed Mushroom Burger is moist, delicious, and stuffed with the perfect amount of cheese.
This epic burger is part of a fan-frickin-tastic month long event hosted by Girl Carnivore, but opinions are always my own!

It’s #BURGERMONTH! I have been waiting for this month since last year was over. And this year I’m aiming for a burger every week again. It’s a challenge, but I am up for it! Are you? This year some of them are not as over the top as last year, but I’m going out with a bang at the end of the month. You’ll just have to wait to see.
I wanna say that Girl Carnivore has been hosting this event for going on 6 years now? I think it started in 2014. At least that’s as far back as I can find. I have been participating for the last 3 years. At least I think that’s how long I’ve participated. I could be wrong. Maybe it’s been 2 years. Maybe I should check? Yes! This is year three for me.

I think last year was the most fun. I had some off the charts burgers to share. And they were oh so delicious! My fave was the corned beef hash burger. The corned beef was IN the burger mix. I might do something similar this year with one of my burgers; putting something unusual in the burger mix. Just have to see how one recipe plays out.
This burger is inspired by Shake Shack.
Now, I have never been to Shake Shack. “So how do you know about their Mozzarella mushroom burger?” you ask? Well, I participated in an outing at work where we had lunch with some new team members and then checked out a few exhibits at a portrait. I will try NOT to go into what ensued after lunch.

Since I’m a planner and usually bring my lunch, I did just that. I brough a sandwich and some chips because I knew there wouldn’t be a microwave for me to heat anything up. My manager and a few others on the team? Well, they weren’t as planny as me. One brought something to heat up and the others either forgot or just decided to purchase lunch anyway.
Across the street and down a little ways from the portrait gallery is a Shake Shack. A few of the team members rounded up orders, placed them, then went to pick them up before lunch. Since my manager is pescatarian, she ordered their mushroom burger which is stuffed with cheese. Like a TON of cheese! I think she pulled at least 4 ounces of cheese out of the burger and there was still plenty of cheese in the burger.

But that’s not what caught my attention. What caught my attention was the simple thought of a Mozzarella stuffed mushroom burger. I am only assuming the cheese was Mozzarella but I have no idea. I could probably check out their website just to be sure, but it doesn’t really matter.
What matters is how delicious this Mozzarella Stuffed Mushroom Burger tastes!
The mushrooms add rich earthiness that pairs well with the steak seasoning. They also add some moisture that keeps the burgers from drying out. Since I use a low fat content ground beef, I always make sure there’s something in there to keep the burgers from turning into hockey pucks.

Yes, that means you can use ground pork, turkey, or even chicken with this recipe. They will still be moist and delicious from all those minced mushrooms in the mix. And with the steak seasoning, it takes you to your favorite steakhouse and the aromas and flavors they have.
Don’t you love how I give you options with some of my recipes?
There’s even the option to chose whatever cheese you want. Usually, I’m a mushroom Swiss person. So, feel free to use Swiss, Jarlsberg, or even Gruyere in there. However, if Swiss isn’t your cup of tea, then try some Cheddar or even blue cheese! Granted blue cheese doesn’t melt like other cheese so they’re not going to be so gooey in the middle.

I’m going to ask you to ignore that huge mayo blob there. That’s the thing with ciabatta bread; it has large holes in it. And one of those large holes ate up a bunch of mayonnaise. Because, well, I can’t eat a burger without some sauce on it; mayo, mustard, aioli, etc. It’s just another layer of flavor to make your burger that much more awesomely delicious.
Now, can we talk about that cheese oozing out of the middle the burger?
All that Mozzarella goodness just fills the burger perfectly. And as if that’s not enough, I topped them with slices of Mozzarella cheese when they came off the grill. Because, well, you can’t have too much cheese on a burger. At least that’s my opinion. I’m sure I’m not the only one with that thought process.

And, as if that wasn’t enough!
I sautéed some mushrooms to put on top of the burger. I always let the mushrooms get extra crispy on the edges. It adds so much flavor when they have a nice caramelization on there. That brings out the earthy flavor of the mushrooms even more.
And of course, I had to put some lettuce and tomato on my burger. Not so much with the onion. They don’t agree with me the older I get. I could have added onions to the mushrooms when they were cooking, but I really did want this burger to be all about the mushrooms and the Mozzarella.

Mozzarella Stuffed Mushroom Burger
Inspired by the Shake Shack mushroom burger, this Mozzarella Stuffed Mushroom Burger is moist, delicious, and stuffed with the perfect amount of cheese.
Ingredients
- 4 pounds lean ground beef
- 1 1/2 cups finely chopped mushrooms (Your choice of mushrooms. I used white buttons.)
- 1 tablespoon steak seasoning
- 2 teaspoons garlic salt, divided
- 1 1/2 teaspoon black pepper, divided
- 2 cups shredded Mozzarella cheese
- 2 teaspoons olive oil
- 1 teaspoon butter
- 2 cups sliced mushrooms (see above)
- 4 hamburger buns
- 3 ounces sliced Mozzarella cheese (4 slices)
- Other toppings of choice (tomatoes, onions, pickles, etc.)
Instructions
- Preheat grill to high heat.
- Combine the ground beef with the finely chopped mushrooms, steak seasoning, 1 1/2 teaspoons garlic salt and 1 teaspoon black pepper. Be careful not to overmix the ground beef.
- Using a ball of meat slightly larger than a golf ball, form a patty and place it on a plate. Repeat with remaining ground beef until you have 8 thin patties.
- Hold one of the patties in your hand and place half the shredded Mozzarella cheese in the center. Top with another patty and press the edges to seal the two patties together. Shape the patties into a more burger style shape (You’ll see what I mean when you press the two pieces together.).
- Place the burger back on the plate and repeat with the remaining patties and shredded Mozzarella cheese.
- Grill the burgers 2 minutes. Rotate the burgers 45 degrees (for those epic grill marks) and grill another 2 minutes. Flip the burgers over and repeat.
- Top the burgers with cheese and cook 1 more minute before putting them on a clean plate. Over with foil and allow them to rest 5 minutes.
- While the burgers are cooking, heat a non-stick skillet over medium-high heat. Melt the butter and add the olive oil. Sauté the mushrooms until golden brown. Season with the remaining garlic salt and black pepper.
- After the burgers have rest, place them on a bun and top with the sautéed mushrooms and your toppings of choice.
Nutrition Information
Yield
4Serving Size
1Amount Per Serving Calories 1442Total Fat 74gSaturated Fat 31gTrans Fat 2gUnsaturated Fat 33gCholesterol 451mgSodium 2213mgCarbohydrates 36gFiber 4gSugar 8gProtein 152g
Yeah, I don't buy that. Eat at your own risk.
More Delicious Burger Recipes
Juicy Lucy Thanksgiving Sliders
Leftover cranberry sauce and cheese from your charcuterie board combines to make Juicy Lucy Thanksgiving Sliders! A fun and delicious lunch for the family.
Carolina Chicken Burgers
Carolina Chicken Burgers have all the flavors of delicious Carolina mustard barbecue sauce in the burger. It’s a deliciously mustard kick to a regular chicken burger.
ULTIMATE Mushroom Swiss Patty Melt
Not just any patty melt, this ULTIMATE Mushroom Swiss Patty Melt has a different twist on the traditional sandwich with shallots, oyster mushrooms, baby Swiss, and Parmesan coated, extra crispy bread.
French Onion Soup Burger
The caramelized onions make this French Onion Soup Burger over the top. It's a labor of love but makes for one killer burger.
Chalupa Burger
Looking for a burger that's anything but basic? Try the Chalupa Burger. It's bold, flavorful and will take your taste buds on an adventure.
Barbecued Pork Burgers
Barbecued Pork Burgers not only have barbecue sauce, but also a Smoky Honey seasoning bland that makes them smoky and sweet.
Hamburger and Hotdog Spiedini Hoagies
Tired of the same old burgers and hotdogs at your cookouts? Switch things up with our Hamburger and Hotdog Spiedini Hoagies and elevate your grilling game!
Truffle Smashburger
Truffle Smashburgers are quick and easy to whip up any time. The American classic gets glammed up with truffle Cheddar cheese.
Hot Brown Burger
The Hot Brown Burger is a double decker turkey burger topped with bacon, tomato, and a rich cheddar Mornay sauce. Grab a bib because this burger is deliciously messy.
Double Decker Brunch Burger
Double Decker Brunch Burger is just that. Brunch on a bun. It starts with two smashed patties topped with cheese. The top layer has a fried egg and bacon and there’s a waffle in the middle making it an epic double decker burger.
Chorizo and Mushroom Wagyu Burger
Chorizo and Mushroom Wagyu Burger are decadent, topped with rich mushrooms and chorizo with melted Emmental cheese on top. There’s a kicked up mushroom Swiss burger for sure!
Carne Asada Burger with Chipotle Guacamole
Upgrade your next BBQ with this flavorful Sink Your Teeth Into a Carne Asada Burger with Chipotle Guacamole. Say goodbye to bland patties and hello to juicy and flavorful!
Spicy Bulgogi Burger
Spicy Bulgogi Burger is packed with garlic and ginger flavor, spicy Asian sauce, and topped with thinly sliced carrots and radishes. It’s a flavor and texture packed yum on a bun!
Garbage Plate Burger
The Garbage Plate Burger is my homage to the college town I lived in for 5 years. The Garbage Plate is an icon in that area, and for good reason!
Other White Meat Burgers
Since chickpeas, black beans, and lentils are common in veggie burgers, I took mine a different route. These Other White Meat Burgers are made with delicious and delicate cannelini beans.
Italian Sausage Parmesan Burger on Texas Toast
Italian sausage and ground pork come together in this Italian Sausage Parmesan Burger. It's packed with Italian flavors, topped with cheese, and sits on top of spaghetti and Texas toast garlic bread. #BurgerMonth
Rabbit Sausage Burger
Rabbit Sausage Burger with Carrot Horseradish Aioli packs some serious flavors! Inspired by a burger challenge, this is one stellar burger that tastes amazing. @igourmet
Corned Beef Hash Burger
Corned Beef Hash Burger is just what you’re thinking. Corned beef laced burger topped with crispy potatoes and a friend egg. Not to mention the sautéed cabbage and stout mustard seed dijonnaise.
Apple Cheddar Chicken Burgers with Squash Chips
Change up your burger routine with these mouthwatering Apple Cheddar Chicken Burgers! The perfect blend of sweet and savory.
Chicken Piccata Burger with Roasted Radish Aioli
Chicken Piccata Burgers have a hint of lemon, fresh spinach, grated onion, and capers. Yes, capers are in the burger. It’s topped with a delicious roasted radish aioli.
Asian Inspired Short Rib Burger
Asian Inspired Short Rib Burger has soy, ginger, sesame oil, and hoisin sauce. It's topped with braised short ribs marinated with lemongrass, garlic, ginger, and soy sauce and crispy fennel chips. It's packs mouthful after delicious mouthful of flavor.
Mole Burger with Avocado Salsa
Give burger night a bold new twist! This juicy mole spiced burger layers smoky ancho chile, cocoa, cumin, and cinnamon with a bright, chunky avocado salsa. It is fresh, satisfying, and easy enough for a weeknight. Serve it with crisp toppings and your favorite fries or slaw.
Kentucky Burger with Bourbon Onions and Pimento Beer Cheese
Kentucky Burger with Bourbon Onions and Pimento Beer Cheese is an homage to my family and childhood memories. From the pimento cheese combined with beer cheese to the bourbon onions and pickled okra topping everything on this burger reminds me of home. #BurgerMonth
Turkapple Burgers with Yumback Sauce
Take a bite of heaven with Turkapple Burgers and our mouth-watering Yumback Sauce. The ultimate summer grilling combo.
Greek Lamb Burgers with Blistered Tomatoes and Tzatziki Spread
Greek Lamb Burgers have all the delicious flavors of the Mediterranean in one bite! Plus, the blistered tomatoes and Tzatziki spread take them to the next level!
Bacon Cheeseburger Mini Meatloaf Patties
Attention all bacon enthusiasts! These Bacon Cheeseburger Mini Meatloaf Patties are a must-try. Full of flavor, easy to make, and perfect for any gathering. Don't miss out on this perfect combination of cheeseburger and meatloaf.
Greek Style Burgers
Greek Style Burgers are packed with flavor and perfect for your next BBQ. Filled with Mediterranean flavors including sun-dried tomatoes, they’re a guaranteed crowd-pleaser.
Chicken Fajita Burgers
Packed with fajita seasoning and tasty vegetables, these Chicken Fajita Burgers are not only tasty, but healthy, too!
Chipotle Chicken Burgers
Satisfy your cravings and spice up your meal with our mouth-watering Chipotle Chicken Burgers! They're bold and flavorful, guaranteed to shake up your burger game!
Green Chile Quinoa Burgers
Looking for a healthier burger option? Try Green Chile Quinoa Burgers, packed with protein, flavor, and all the spicy goodness of green chiles.
Chicken Apple Brat Burgers
Step up your burger game with our Chicken Apple Brat Burgers - a delicious twist on a classic dish. Juicy, flavorful and perfect for any summer BBQ or tailgate party.
Thai Red Curry Shrimp Burger with Blueberry Chutney
Thai Red Curry Shrimp Burger is a perfect blend of fresh shrimp and fragrant Thai red curry. This burger is sure to please seafood lovers with its combination of bold flavors and tender texture.
Authentic Loco Moco Hawaiian Burger
This Authentic Loco Moco Hawaiian Burger sits on top of a rice patty and traditional Hawaiian macaroni salad and is topped with the rich beef gravy and a sunny side up egg.
Mushroom Swiss Mushroom Swiss Burgers
Burgers are the epitome of the welcome mat to summer. Just walk right on in, grab a bun, some chips or potato salad, a burger, and have a seat at the picnic table.
Courgette and Ricotta Falafel Burgers
Falafel meets zucchini fritter in this recipe mash up. Courgette and Ricotta Falafel Burgers are healthy, delicious, and perfect for a meatfree meal!
Satay Burger with Tamarind Fig Peanut Sauce
Satay Burger with Tamarind Fig Peanut Sauce has a juicy pork patty topped with a complex tamarind fig satay sauce that's irresistible! The sweet tamarind and fig is paired with the salty soy and oyster sauces with a kick of ginger.
Pork Taco Burgers with Red Hot Pickled Mangoes
What do you make with pork, avocado, mango, and red hots? Pork Taco Burgers with Red Hot Mango Pickles topped with avocado crema. @redduckfoods @CabotCheese
Hot Hamburger
Experience the rich flavors of Hot Hamburger (Salisbury Steak) with this simple and satisfying dish. Each patty is cooked to perfection and topped with flavorful gravy, making it ideal for quick weeknight meals or special occasions.
Hot Hamburger Hoagie
Forget about boring old burgers. Step up your burger game with a hot hamburger hoagie! Stuffed with satueed ground beef, gooey cheese, and loaded with all your favorite toppings. Trust us, you won't be able to put it down
This Pizza Burger Bomb is layered with pizza flavors
This Pizza Burger Bomb combines a fun dinner roll with a delicious hamburger. A seared burger gets a topping of pizza sauce, pepperoni, and cheese and a wrapping of delicious pizza dough for a fun twist on a burger.
Week 1 #BurgerMonth Recipes
- Stuffed Jalapeño Popper Burger by Our Good Life
- Mozzarella Stuffed Mushroom Burger by A Kitchen Hoor’s Adventures
- Blueberry Cinnamon Roll Turkey Burger by The Spiffy Cookie
- Jucy Lucy Burger by Palatable Pastime
- Taco Burger by Real Life With Dad
- Polish Kielbasa and Pierogi Burger by “Savoring Midlife”

What a mouthwatering burger!. I love my burger with a a lot cheese like this one.
Thank you! I’m all about the cheese with burgers.